Texas Judge Says HIV Drug Mandate Violates Religious Freedom

PrEP drugs can cost as much as $20,000 a year, according to the ruling.

Task Force Unconstitutional

In another win for the plaintiffs, O’Connor ruled the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force, or PSTF, which makes recommendations for what qualifies as a covered preventive measure under the ACA, is unconstitutional because it “wields a power to compel private action that resembles legislative authority.”

“Because PSTF members are principal officers, they must be appointed by the President and confirmed by the Senate,” O’Connor said. “The PSTF members indisputably fail that constitutional requirement.”

The judge also reserved ruling on the appropriate remedy for dealing with that alleged violation.

The judge dismissed a claim that challenged the preventive mandate itself, though it’s unclear how the provision might be affected by the rest of the ruling.

Mitchell seeks to block the entire preventive services mandate under the ACA, arguing it’s invalid because the government employees who manage the list have too much power to not be confirmed by the Senate. Depending on O’Connor’s remedy in the case, that could have a far-reaching impact nationwide, putting at risk requirements for no-cost access to other services, like care for pregnant women and infants.

O’Connor didn’t entirely side with Mitchell. The judge ruled that two other bodies involved in ACA preventive services, the Health Resources and Services Administration and the Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices, were properly empowered under the constitution. The judge also ruled that the Preventive Services Task Force doesn’t violate a separate provision of the constitution.

The case is Braidwood Management Inc. v. Becerra, 4:20-cv-00283, U.S. District Court, Northern District of Texas (Fort Worth).

(Image: Sergign/Adobe Stock)