Could U.S.-style conservative backlash against ESG come to Canada?

But, even while it’s become part of mainstream investing, with more institutions getting involved and more investors willing to pay higher fees for it, Lowsen noted some Republican states in the U.S. have recently passed legislation restricting the ability of state pension funds and other state assets to be invested with assets managers interested in a net-zero commitment to fossil fuels.

“It’s dominated by Texas and Louisiana,” she said. “Texas, of course, is a big oil producing state with an economy that’s very closely connected to fossil fuels. So, I think they fear that something fundamental to their state economy is changing – and, frankly, it is, because the energy transition really is here.

“All of the economics are in place, not to mention the need to arrest climate change. So, there has been some backlash because they are trying to say that considering ESG factors violate an investment manager’s fiduciary duty. That really doesn’t hold water, particularly if ESG factors are material to performance. So, I don’t think their argument is a strong one, but it is political.”

Read More: Do you really want to change the world with ESG investing? | Wealth Professional

While she noted that the dissent was still localized in a few states, her company, a dedicated ESG manager which was founded in 2016, is waiting to see if the courts uphold the new laws. But, while she warned about similar concerns being raised in Canada, she also noted that the states doing this have targeted a small number of the world’s largest asset managers and that could impact Canadian financial advisors who are investing their clients’ funds with these managers.