Refusal to pay co-pay for annual dr. visit for renewal of prescription

This is a gong show I observed recently while checking in at my doctor’s office, and it made me ponder this a bit.

A man at another window was arguing with a woman checking him in for his appointment. She had asked him for his co-pay. This is when it went sideways.

Patient: Why do I have to pay for this? The doctor called me to come in, I didn’t call them and request an appointment.

Receptionist: I’m sorry about that. Did you want to cancel your appointment?

Patient: No, because the doctor is calling me all the time non stop. The doctor told me to come in, so I shouldn’t have to pay a co-pay.

Receptionist: Let me check with the doctor. Hold on. (leaves and comes back) I understand, now. You need a refill for a medication and the doctor has not seen you for a year, so before they can refill it, they want to see you.

Patient: I don’t have anything wrong with me and don’t need to see the doctor. They can call me on the phone and talk to me about this, why do I need to see the doctor and pay for an appointment when there’s nothing wrong with me?

I had to leave at that point so I’m not sure how it ended. I was mostly amused at the wordplay involved, but it got me thinking about a larger issue. I have also had to see a doctor after 12 months to refill a prescription and it was a 10 minute visit. Is the medication still working for you? Any new side effects? Anything change in your lifestyle that we need to be aware of? Ok here’s another 12-month prescription.

For people that live paycheck to paycheck, a co-pay at the doctor, in addition to taking the time off work to go for a visit, can be disruptive. While there may be some medication that is dangerous if not monitored closely, there are definitely routine medications that shouldn’t be given a prescription for in perpetuity, but a non-billable phone call to see if the person is still actually taking it should suffice.

Is there a way a person would be able to continue to get their medication without paying for a doctor visit?