My EOB says my amount due was lower than what I paid at my (new) PCP… What next?

Tldr; paid a copay of $60, EOB says I should have paid $20. Do I bring EOB paperwork to PCP office to get a refund? Would that be enough? Will they be weird about it?

Never had like actual, real health insurance before! Still trying to figure it all out. This is a very low stakes question, especially compared to some of the ones I’ve seen here.

I set up an appointment with a potential PCP for June 12, went in, paid my copay ($60), and bam badda boom all good. I was expecting the copay to be $20 according to the insurance documents, but I justified it as maybe this was a Tier 2 office (as opposed to a Tier 1?) or it was being considered a Specialist visit for whatever reason (maybe because I was doing a whole new patient physical? Or because I was bringing up a specific health concern?).

Anyway, as you may have gathered, I got my EOB from the insurance and yeah, the copay should have been $20. I also talked to an insurance agent to confirm that I was reading the paperwork right, that I did not owe the PCP office an additional $20, I only ever owed $20 period and since I paid them $60, I had overpaid.

So – I know I would go to the healthcare provider office for a refund. But will the EOB paperwork suffice as evidence I was overcharged and due a refund? I don’t want them thinking I’m like, dissatisfied with care or being shady or trying to pull a fast one or anything weird. And I’m awkward so this is awful for me to deal with. đź«  Any advice?

See also  Health insurance for restaurant employees, chefs and waitstaff

Apologies because I like to ramble.