Can’t decide which health insurance to get…

I’m getting health insurance for the first time in my life (24M) and it’s been very confusing, but I’ve narrowed it down to 2 plans.

Blue Cross Premier PPO Bronze

Blue Cross Local HMO Bronze Extra

Premium

$318

$230

Deductible

$8,000

Individual total

(health & drug combined)

$7,500

Individual total

(health & drug combined)

Out of pocket max

$8,000 Individual total

$9,400 Individual total

Primary care doctor visit

In Network: No charge after deductible

Out of Network: No charge after deductible

In Network: $50 per visit from day 1

Out of Network: Benefit not covered

Specialist visit

In Network: No charge after deductible

Out of Network: No charge after deductible

In Network: $100 per visit from day 1

Out of Network: Benefit not covered

X-rays and diagnostic imaging

In Network: No charge after deductible

Out of Network: No charge after deductible

In Network: 50% coinsurance after deductible

Out of Network: Benefit not covered

Blue Cross Local HMO Bronze Extra seems better to me and is cheaper, but you are locked into their network. Is it worth is to go PPO over HMO? I don’t currently have a primary doctor so I’m not sure which to pick here.

See also  Ending Covered California and unsure which plan to switch to next. Help!