Am I being offered good health insurance programs?

Hello everyone,

I am trying to decide between 4 different healthcare plans I have available to me right now. 3 are being offered through an employer and 1 is a self-pay plan that I found elsewhere. For context I am a healthy 29 y/o male, but I do want to be covered so I am not totally destroyed financially if something happens. I am already in medical debt and don’t need anymore.

First Plan: $120/mo

$3,500 deductible

$7,500 out of pocket MAX

all services other than preventative care are 30% AD

So it makes me think I am pretty much going to be paying the full amount for everything I do unless I go to the ER or something.

Second Plan: $280/mo

$1,500 deductible

$6,600 out of pocket MAX

Office visits have a $20-50 copay

Urgent Care $50 copay

Telehealth $10 copay

Everything else 20% AD

Obviously this is the best plan, but $280/mo seems so expensive.

Third Plan: $177/mo

$2,000 deductible

$6,450 out of pocket MAX

Preventative care covered 100%

All other services 20% AD

Fourth Plan: $230/mo

This is the one not being offered through my employer, not sure I understand it, it says:

Coinsurance: PPO 80%/20% (what does this mean?)

$5,000 deductible

Doctor office visits $100/3 visits

Diagnostic lab tests $40/3 days

Diagnostic X-Ray $75/2 days

Urgent Care $100/1 day

Physical $125/1 exam

EKG $50/ 1 exam

Stress EKG $100/1 exam

Colonoscopy $450/1 exam

So if anyone has any input I would appreciate it. As far as deductible/out-of-pocket MAX goes, what is the difference? Is a deductible for each individual visit and out-of-pocket max for the year? Any input is appreciated!

See also  Was CC'ed on letter from my insurance to my provider saying their final appeal was denied. Unsure how it affects me.