Affordable Health Insurance for Small Business Employees

With the ever-evolving needs of your workforce and the complexities of various insurance options, finding the right fit for affordable health insurance can be a daunting task. This guide is designed to provide clarity, particularly highlighting the advantages of Health Reimbursement Arrangements (HRAs) as a viable alternative to traditional group insurance.

As you delve into the world of health insurance, understanding the nuances of different plans becomes key. This includes exploring HRAs, such as QSEHRA and ICHRA, which offer flexibility and cost control, potentially making them a more suitable option for small businesses compared to conventional group plans. You’ll discover how these plans not only fit within your budget but also cater to the diverse needs of your employees, allowing them to choose health insurance plans that work best for them. Embracing HRAs could be a strategic move for your business, balancing financial prudence with the provision of valuable employee benefits. 

Cost of Health Insurance for Small Businesses

Understanding the cost dynamics of health insurance is crucial for you as a small business owner or HR decision-maker. Navigating these costs effectively is not just about budgeting; it’s about making strategic choices that benefit both your business and your employees.

→ Read our health insurance market snapshot

What Costs Can You Expect?

The reality is, providing health insurance can be a significant investment. Recent reports, like the 2021 Kaiser Family Foundation study, highlight some eye-opening figures. For instance, the average annual health insurance premium for small firms was around $7,813 for single coverage and $21,804 for family coverage. As a small business, you’re typically expected to contribute a substantial portion of these premiums, with many employers covering over 80% for single coverage and around 63% for family coverage.

Legal Requirements and Business Size

The size of your business plays a key role in determining your health insurance obligations. Businesses with fewer than 50 employees are not legally required to offer health insurance. However, statistics show that a significant percentage choose to provide this benefit even if not legally obligated to do so. The Kaiser Family Foundation reports that 39% of firms with 3-9 workers offer coverage, compared to 58% of firms with 10-24 workers, 73% of firms with 25-49 workers.

Balancing Cost and Benefits

As you weigh the costs, it’s important to consider the value that health insurance brings to your business. While it is a financial commitment, providing health insurance can be a powerful tool for attracting and retaining top talent, ultimately contributing to the health and growth of your business.

What Health Insurance Options are Available for Small Businesses?

As a small business owner or someone in charge of HR, understanding the range of health insurance options for small businesses is crucial. Each option has its own set of benefits and considerations, allowing you to choose a plan that best aligns with your business’s needs and budget.

Small Group Health Insurance

Small group health insurance is a common choice for many small businesses. It involves purchasing a group health insurance policy that you offer to your employees. These plans are generally easier to qualify for and can offer a range of coverage options. The key advantage here is the pooling of risk, which can sometimes lead to more favorable rates compared to individual plans.

Related: Smart Alternatives to Group Health Insurance

Health Reimbursement Plans (HRAs)

HRAs are becoming increasingly popular among small businesses due to their flexibility and cost-effectiveness. They allow you to reimburse employees for medical expenses, including individual health insurance premiums, tax-free. Two notable types of HRAs are:

Individual Coverage Health Reimbursement Arrangement (ICHRA): This plan allows you to offer different benefits to different employee classes and has no limit on annual employer contributions.

Qualified Small Employer Health Reimbursement Arrangement (QSEHRA): Tailored for smaller businesses with fewer than 50 employees, QSEHRA has set contribution limits and offers both flexibility and simplicity.

Related: Pros & Cons of a Group Plan vs QSEHRA vs Stipends

Health Stipends

Health stipends are a straightforward approach where you provide a fixed amount of money to employees to purchase their own health insurance or cover medical expenses. This option offers simplicity and flexibility but lacks the tax advantages of HRAs.

Related: Health Stipends vs Insurance 

Self-Insured Plan

A self-insured plan, or a self-funded plan, is where your business assumes the financial risk of providing healthcare benefits to employees. While this option can offer significant cost savings and customization, it is generally more suited to larger businesses due to the financial risk involved.

Tax Advantages of HRAs Over Traditional Group Plans

Previously, one of the key benefits of traditional group health plans was their tax efficiency. Employers could deduct these expenses, and the contributions were typically made pre-tax from employee paychecks. However, the landscape of health insurance has evolved, particularly with the introduction of Health Reimbursement Arrangements (HRAs).

With an HRA, the dynamic shifts favorably for both you and your employees. As an employer, you can reimburse health insurance costs without the burden of payroll taxes. For your employees, these reimbursements are not recognized as taxable income. And the reimbursements you provide count as a tax deduction for your business. This simplifies the financial aspects of providing health insurance but also enhances the overall tax efficiency of your benefits package.

What Health Insurance Options are Most Affordable for Small Businesses?

As you seek to provide health insurance for your employees, one of the primary concerns is undoubtedly the cost. Affordability is key, especially for small businesses operating with tighter budgets. Let’s explore some of the most cost-effective health insurance options available to you.

Evaluating Group Health Insurance Costs

While traditional small group health insurance is a popular choice, it’s important to weigh its cost against the benefits it offers. In 2022, it was noted that employers contributed about $6,500 annually towards each employee’s individual coverage premiums, and around $16,300 for family coverage. Although group plans can offer comprehensive coverage, the rising costs are a significant consideration for small businesses.

The Financial Appeal of HRAs

HRAs offer the flexibility to control costs while still providing substantial health benefits. With ICHRA, there’s no cap on contributions, and it allows for varied benefits across different employee classes. On the other hand, QSEHRA, specifically designed for businesses with fewer than 50 employees, offers a more structured approach with set contribution limits. Both options can be more budget-friendly compared to traditional group plans.

The Simplicity of Health Stipends

Health stipends are another avenue worth considering for their simplicity and direct control over costs. You can allocate a fixed sum to employees for their health care needs, allowing them to choose how best to spend it. While this option might lack the tax benefits of HRAs, it provides a straightforward approach to supporting employee health care without the complexity of managing a traditional insurance plan.

Self-Insured Plans: A Closer Look

Self-insured plans can offer cost savings, particularly for businesses willing to take on more risk. However, it’s important to note that while self-insured plans can be tailored to specific needs and potentially reduce costs, they are generally more suitable for larger businesses with the financial resilience to absorb potential high costs of care.

When considering these options, it’s essential to balance affordability with the needs and well-being of your employees. An effective health insurance plan is not just about the lowest cost; it’s about finding the right fit for your business and your team.

Understood! Let’s refocus the section on the considerations when choosing health insurance for employees, highlighting the benefits of Health Reimbursement Arrangements (HRAs) as provided by Take Command, an HRA administration platform.

What Considerations Should You Make When Considering Insurance for Employees?

When it comes to selecting health insurance for your employees, there are several key factors to consider. As a business owner or HR manager, your decision not only affects your bottom line but also plays a crucial role in employee satisfaction and the overall management of the plan. Let’s explore why offering an HRA, especially through a platform like Take Command, can be the best option on all fronts.

Cost: A Financially Sound Choice

The primary consideration for most businesses is cost. HRAs, particularly those managed through platforms like Take Command, offer a financially advantageous solution. Unlike traditional group plans, HRAs provide a predictable cost structure, allowing you to set a fixed budget for reimbursements. This predictability eliminates the financial uncertainties often associated with group health plans, making it a cost-effective choice for your business.

Employee Benefits: Empowering Personal Choice

One of the unique advantages of HRAs is the empowerment they offer to your employees. Unlike group plans where employees are confined to the options you choose, HRAs allow them to select their own health insurance plans. This flexibility ensures that employees can choose a plan that best suits their individual or family needs, leading to higher satisfaction and appreciation for the benefits you offer. 

Management: Simplifying Administration

Offering an HRA, particularly through an administration platform like Take Command, significantly simplifies the management of health benefits. The platform streamlines the reimbursement process, reducing the time and effort you need to dedicate to managing the health insurance plan. This ease of administration not only benefits you as an employer but also ensures a smooth experience for your employees, making the entire process of health insurance more efficient and user-friendly.

Ready to start and HRA for your small business? Chat with one of our HRA experts today!

→ Book a call

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Navigating health insurance options can be particularly challenging due to the diverse nature of business structures. Here, we address some common queries to help you understand which health insurance options are most affordable, depending on your business type.

What Health Insurance is Most Affordable for an LLC?

For Limited Liability Companies (LLCs), the affordability of health insurance often depends on the size and structure of the company. For smaller LLCs, QSEHRAs (Qualified Small Employer Health Reimbursement Arrangements) are often a cost-effective choice, providing flexibility and control over costs. For larger LLCs, traditional group health insurance plans might offer more comprehensive coverage but at a higher cost. 

What Health Insurance is Most Affordable for an S-Corp?

S-Corporations have unique tax considerations that can impact the affordability of health insurance. An ICHRA (Individual Coverage Health Reimbursement Arrangement) can be a suitable option for S-Corps, allowing the business to reimburse employees for their health insurance premiums on a tax-advantaged basis. This plan can be tailored to suit different employee needs and can be more budget-friendly than standard group plans.

What Health Insurance is Most Affordable for a Non-Profit?

Non-profit organizations often operate with strict budget constraints, making affordability a key concern. Group health insurance plans, especially those designed for small to medium-sized organizations, can offer competitive rates with good coverage. Additionally, HRAs can provide an alternative route, allowing non-profits to reimburse employees for individual insurance plans, thereby controlling costs more effectively.

What Health Insurance is Most Affordable for a C-Corp?

C-Corporations, due to their structure, may find traditional group health insurance plans to be the most comprehensive option. These plans can be cost-effective for C-Corps, especially when considering the tax benefits associated with employer-sponsored health insurance. However, for smaller C-Corps, exploring HRAs like ICHRA and QSEHRA could yield more affordable alternatives.